| Year | Team | League | W | L | Playoffs | Division | Champion | Manager |
| 1999 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 21 | 26 | Paul Knight | |||
| 2000 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 19 | 27 | Mike Anderson | |||
| 2001 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 23 | 27 | Brian Rountree | |||
| 2002 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 23 | 24 | Mike Kramer | |||
| 2003 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 33 | 17 | Yes | Yes | Rob Huffstetler | |
| 2004 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 26 | 25 | Yes | Yes | Rob Huffstetler | |
| 2005 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 30 | 26 | Yes | Yes | Josh Jordan | |
| 2006 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 37 | 23 | Yes | Yes | Alan Beck | |
| 2007 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 43 | 17 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Ryan McCurry |
| 2008 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 41 | 20 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Matt McCay |
| 2009 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 26 | 28 | Yes | Tom Dorzweiler | ||
| 2010 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 17 | 37 | Tom Dorzweiler | |||
| 2011
|
HPT HiToms
|
Coastal Plain League | 31 | 25 | Yes | Yes | Jeff Steele
|
|
| 2012 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Lain League | 24 | 30 | Sean Walsh | |||
| 2013 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 26 | 30 | Yes | Zach Brown | ||
| 2014 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 26 | 28 | Yes | Austin Love | ||
| 2015 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 26 | 30 | Brian Rountree | |||
| 2016 | HPT HiToms | Coastal PLain League | 30 | 26 | Yes | Brian Rountree | ||
| 2017 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 29 | 25 | Yes | Brian Rountree | ||
| 2018 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 36 | 20 | Yes | Yes | Runner-Up | Brian Rountree |
| 2019 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 28 | 27 | Brian Rountree | |||
| 2020 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 24 | 7 | N/A | Yes | N/A | Mickey Williard |
| 2021 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 32 | 22 | Yes | Scott Davis | ||
| 2022 | HPT HiToms | Coastal Plain League | 27 | 25 | DJ Russ |