| Year | Team | League | W | L | Playoffs | Champion | Manager |
| 1937 | Thomasville Chair Makers | NC State | 63 | 48 | Yes | Jimmy Maus | |
| 1938 | Thomasville Orioles | NC State | 75 | 36 | Yes | Yes | Jimmy Maus |
| 1939 | Thomasville Tommies | NC State | 58 | 52 | Yes | Jimmy Maus | |
| 1940 | Thomasville Tommies | NC State | 56 | 54 | Jimmy Maus | ||
| 1941 | Thomasville Tommies | NC State | 56 | 44 | Yes | Jim Gruzdis | |
| 1942 | Thomasville Tommies | NC State | 61 | 39 | Yes | Yes | Jim Gruzdis/Woody Mabry |
| 1945 | Thomasville Tommies | NC State | 40 | 72 | Red Kaiser/Rex Bowen | ||
| 1946 | Thomasville Dodgers | NC State | 58 | 52 | Yes | John Carey/Jay Kirke Jr. | |
| 1947 | Thomasville Dodgers | NC State | 54 | 56 | George Pratt/George Scherger | ||
| 1948 | HP-Thom. HiToms | NC State | 67 | 43 | Yes | Jim Gruzdis | |
| 1949 | HP-Thom. HiToms | NC State | 90 | 34 | Yes | Yes | Jim Gruzdis |
| 1950 | HP-Thom. HiToms | NC State | 61 | 50 | Yes | Jim Gruzdis | |
| 1951 | HP-Thom. HiToms | NC State | 90 | 36 | Yes | Yes | Jim Gruzdis |
| 1952 | HP-Thom. HiToms | NC State | 74 | 33 | Yes | Jim Gruzdis | |
| 1953 | HP-Thom. HiToms | Tar Heal | 13 | 28 | Jim Gruzdis/John Lybrand | ||
| 1954 | HP-Thom. HiToms | Carolina | 66 | 73 | Tome Reis/Don Padgett | ||
| 1955 | HP-Thom. HiToms | Carolina | 80 | 58 | Yes | James Brown | |
| 1956 | HP-Thom. HiToms | Carolina | 91 | 63 | Yes | Bert Haas | |
| 1957 | HP-Thom. HiToms | Carolina | 79 | 61 | Yes | Frank Lucchesi | |
| 1958 | HP-Thom. HiToms | Carolina | 76 | 63 | Yes | Frank Lucchesi | |
| 1965 | Thomasville HiToms | Western Carolinas | 73 | 52 | Ralph Rowe | ||
| 1966 | Thomasville HiToms | Western Carolinas | 71 | 52 | Ralph Rowe | ||
| 1968 | HP-Thom. HiToms | Carolina | 69 | 71 | Yes | Yes | Jack McKeon |
| 1969 | HP-Thom. HiToms | Carolina | 69 | 74 | Yes | Harry Malmberg |